Thursday 21st September 2023
Opinion in Case C-301/22 Sweetman
(Environment)
Directive 2000/60/EC (EU Water Directive) sets out rules to halt deterioration in the status of the EU water bodies and achieve ‘good status’ for rivers, lakes and groundwater. The directive places clear responsibilities on national authorities in protecting all forms of water – surface, ground, inland and transitional – to reduce pollution in water bodies, prevent degradation, improve the condition of aquatic ecosystems, preserve and restore the ecosystems in and around those.
The Irish High court referred a number of questions concerning the obligation of the Member States to characterize and then classify the ecological status of the lakes within its territory. The High Court asks whether this responsibility covers all lakes, including the ones with a surface area of less than 0.5 km2 (the minimum threshold). If this is answered in the negative, the High Court asks whether the directive creates any obligations on Member States to ensure the protection of such a water body when a development project is likely to affect it.
These questions follow on from the judgment of 1 July 2015, Bund für Umwelt und Naturschutz Deutschland (C-461/13), in which the Court held that, subject to the granting of a derogation, any deterioration in the status of a body of water must be avoided, irrespective of the longer-term planning provided for by management plans and programmes of measures.
The dispute between M. Peter Sweetman and An Bord Pleanála (the Agency) stems from the authorization granted by the Agency to the Bradán Beo Teoranta company to extract fresh water from Loch an Mhuilinn, under specific conditions and in specific amounts. The plan was for the water to be pumped from the lake, through a pipeline, to bathe sick salmon to rid them of amoebic gill disease and sea lice. The lake in question is a private inland non-tidal lake located on Gorumna Island, County Galway, Ireland, with a surface area of 0.083 km2 or 8.3 hectares.
It had not been identified by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) as a body of water covered by the Water Directive, because it did not meet the criteria relating to surface area or location in a protected area. As a result, the EPA had not classified the lake’s ecological status.
Mr Sweetman appealed against this decision to the High Court, arguing that, by authorizing the development project, the Agency had breached its obligation to take the necessary measures to prevent deterioration in the status of this body of surface water.
By judgment of January 15, 2021, the referring court annulled the decision to authorize the development project on the sole ground that it did not comply with the requirements of the EU Water Directive.
Relying on the European Commission’s guidance document no. 2, entitled “Identification of water bodies”, the EPA had stated that there was no obligation to classify the ecological status of all bodies of water and to classify the lake’s ecological status .According to that document, Member States would have the flexibility to decide whether the objectives of the directive, applying to all surface waters, can be achieved without having to identify each minor element of surface water as a body of water.
Minor lakes can be subject to the EU Water Directive, if they are ecologically significant, if they fall within one of the protected areas, or if they have a significant negative impact on other bodies of surface water.
We and use cookies and other tracking technologies to improve your experience on our website. We may store and/or access information on a device and process personal data, such as your IP address and browsing data, for personalised advertising and content, advertising and content measurement, audience research and services development. Additionally, we may utilize precise geolocation data and identification through device scanning.
Please note that your consent will be valid across all our subdomains. You can change or withdraw your consent at any time by clicking the “Consent Preferences” button at the bottom of your screen. We respect your choices and are committed to providing you with a transparent and secure browsing experience.
Cookie | Duration | Description |
---|---|---|
__stripe_mid | This cookie is set by Stripe payment gateway. This cookie is used to enable payment on the website without storing any patment information on a server. | |
__stripe_sid | This cookie is set by Stripe payment gateway. This cookie is used to enable payment on the website without storing any patment information on a server. | |
_abck | This cookie is used to detect and defend when a client attempt to replay a cookie.This cookie manages the interaction with online bots and takes the appropriate actions. | |
_wpfuuid | This cookie is used by the WPForms WordPress plugin. The cookie is used to allows the paid version of the plugin to connect entries by the same user and is used for some additional features like the Form Abandonment addon. | |
ASP.NET_SessionId | Issued by Microsoft's ASP.NET Application, this cookie stores session data during a user's website visit. | |
AWSALBCORS | This cookie is managed by Amazon Web Services and is used for load balancing. | |
bm_sz | This cookie is set by the provider Akamai Bot Manager. This cookie is used to manage the interaction with the online bots. It also helps in fraud preventions | |
cookielawinfo-checbox-analytics | This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Analytics". | |
cookielawinfo-checbox-functional | The cookie is set by GDPR cookie consent to record the user consent for the cookies in the category "Functional". | |
cookielawinfo-checbox-others | This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Other. | |
cookielawinfo-checkbox-necessary | This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookies is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Necessary". | |
cookielawinfo-checkbox-performance | This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Performance". | |
elementor | This cookie is used by the website's WordPress theme. It allows the website owner to implement or change the website's content in real-time. | |
JSESSIONID | Used by sites written in JSP. General purpose platform session cookies that are used to maintain users' state across page requests. | |
viewed_cookie_policy | The cookie is set by the GDPR Cookie Consent plugin and is used to store whether or not user has consented to the use of cookies. It does not store any personal data. |
Cookie | Duration | Description |
---|---|---|
_ga | The _ga cookie, installed by Google Analytics, calculates visitor, session and campaign data and also keeps track of site usage for the site's analytics report. The cookie stores information anonymously and assigns a randomly generated number to recognize unique visitors. | |
_ga_4L7PKQPHHV | This cookie is installed by Google Analytics. | |
_ga_T50H0MNN9J | This cookie is installed by Google Analytics. | |
_gat_gtag_UA_12289088_5 | Set by Google to distinguish users. | |
_gcl_au | Provided by Google Tag Manager to experiment advertisement efficiency of websites using their services. | |
_gid | Installed by Google Analytics, _gid cookie stores information on how visitors use a website, while also creating an analytics report of the website's performance. Some of the data that are collected include the number of visitors, their source, and the pages they visit anonymously. |
Cookie | Duration | Description |
---|---|---|
test_cookie | The test_cookie is set by doubleclick.net and is used to determine if the user's browser supports cookies. |
Cookie | Duration | Description |
---|---|---|
_mcid | No description available. | |
_swa_u | This cookie is set by the provider Sitewit.com. This cookie is used for statistical report and analysis. | |
ak_bmsc | No description available. | |
AWSALB | AWSALB is a cookie generated by the Application load balancer in the Amazon Web Services. It works slightly different from AWSELB. | |
ec_store_chameleon_font | No description available. | |
FCCDCF | No description available. | |
issuem_lp | No description available. | |
lp_us_his | No description | |
m | No description available. |