Friday, 25 October 2024
Growing Together with Innovation, Mobility and Sustainability
1. Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Federal Chancellor Olaf Scholz co-chaired the seventh round of India-Germany Inter-Governmental Consultations (7th IGC) on 25 October 2024 in New Delhi. The Delegation included Ministers of Defence, External Affairs, Commerce & Industries, Labour & Employment, Science & Technology (MoS) and Skill Development (MoS) from the Indian side and Ministers of Economic Affairs & Climate Action, Foreign Affairs, Labour & Social Affairs and Education & Research from the German side along with Parliamentary State Secretaries for Finance; Environment, Nature Conservation, Nuclear Safety and Consumer Protection; and Economic Cooperation and Development from the German side, as well as senior officials from both sides.
2. Prime Minister Narendra Modi warmly welcomed Chancellor Olaf Scholz on his third visit to India as Chancellor. Both leaders sincerely appreciated the renewed momentum in bilateral engagement across government, industry, civil society and academia that has played an instrumental role in advancing and deepening the Strategic Partnership between India and Germany.
3. Both leaders emphasised the importance of the Asia-Pacific Conference of German Business (APK), which takes place in New Delhi in parallel to the 7th IGC, in strengthening economic ties and strategic partnerships between Germany, India and the Indo-Pacific region as a whole. The decision to host the 2024 conference in India underscores India’s political weight in the Indo-Pacific and globally.
4. Under the motto “Growing Together with Innovation, Mobility and Sustainability”, the 7th IGC placed particular emphasis on technology and innovation, labour and talent, migration and mobility, climate action, green and sustainable development as well as economic, defence and strategic cooperation. Both sides agree that the aforementioned domains will be the key drivers of our ever more multi-faceted partnership that spans trade, investment, defence, science, technology, innovation, sustainability, renewable energy, emerging technologies, development cooperation, culture, education, sustainable mobility, sustainable resource management, biodiversity, climate resilience and people-to-people ties.
5. The year 2024 marks the 50th anniversary of the signing of the Inter – Governmental Agreement on Cooperation in Scientific Research and Technological Development which institutionalized the framework of Indo-German cooperation in Science & Technology, research and innovation. In this context, the 7th IGC presented an opportunity to renew the close relationship between India and Germany in this regard and to prioritize the advancement of technology and innovation as a key pillar of cooperation.
6. During the 6th IGC, both governments had announced the Green and Sustainable Development Partnership (GSDP), which serves as an umbrella for bilateral formats and joint initiatives in this field. Subsequently, both sides signed the Migration and Mobility Partnership Agreement (MMPA) in December 2022 and launched the “India-Germany Vision to Enhance Cooperation in Innovation and Technology” in February 2023. Recalling the outcomes of the 6th IGC and various agreements concluded by the two sides thereafter, both governments launched the “India-Germany Innovation and Technology Partnership Roadmap” and introduced the “Indo-German Green Hydrogen Roadmap“, whose aim is to promote the market ramp-up of Green Hydrogen.
Growing Together for peace, security and stability
7. The two leaders noted the Pact for the Future and reaffirmed their commitment to upholding shared values and principles including democracy, freedom, international peace and security and a rules-based international order in line with the purposes and principles of the UN Charter. Both governments also underscored their commitment to strengthen and reform the multilateral system including expansion of both permanent and non-permanent categories of membership of the UN Security Council to reflect contemporary realities, address current and future challenges and to support and preserve peace and stability across the world. The two leaders called for text-based negotiations at the IGN within a fixed timeframe.
8. India and Germany agreed that the difficulties of the UN Security Council to effectively address regional and global crises offer a compelling reminder of the urgent need for reform. As members of the “Group of Four (G4)”, India and Germany reiterated their call for a Security Council that is efficient, effective, transparent and reflective of 21st century realities.
9. The leaders expressed their deepest concern over the war raging in Ukraine including its terrible and tragic humanitarian consequences. They reiterated the need for a comprehensive, just, and lasting peace in line with international law, consistent with the purposes and principles of the UN Charter, including respect for sovereignty and territorial integrity. They also noted the negative impacts of the war in Ukraine with regard to global food and energy security, especially for developing and least developed countries. In the context of this war, they shared the view that the use, or threat of use, of nuclear weapons is unacceptable. They underscored the importance of upholding international law, and in line with the UN Charter, reiterated that all states must refrain from the threat of or use of force against the territorial integrity and sovereignty or political independence of any state.
10. The leaders expressed their shared interest in achieving peace and stability in the Middle East. They unequivocally condemned Hamas’ terror attacks on October 7, 2023 and expressed concern over the large-scale loss of civilian lives and the humanitarian crisis in Gaza. They called for the immediate release of all hostages taken by Hamas and an immediate ceasefire as well as the urgent improvement of access and sustained distribution of humanitarian assistance at scale throughout Gaza. The leaders underscored the need to prevent the conflict from escalating and spilling over in the region. In this regard, they called on all regional players to act responsibly and with restraint. Both sides also emphasized the urgent need to protect the lives of civilians and facilitate safe, timely and sustained humanitarian relief to civilians, and in this regard urged all parties to comply with international law. The leaders were also deeply concerned about the rapidly deteriorating situation in Lebanon, called for an urgent cessation of hostilities and agreed that a solution to the conflict in Gaza and in Lebanon can only be reached by diplomatic means. The United Nations Security Council Resolution 1701 outlines the path towards a diplomatic solution along the Blue Line. The leaders reaffirmed their commitment to a negotiated two-state solution, leading to the establishment of a sovereign, viable and independent State of Palestine, living within secure and mutually recognized borders, side by side in dignity and peace with Israel, taking into account Israel’s legitimate security concerns.
11. The leaders underscored that as the world’s two largest democracies, India and the EU have a common interest in ensuring security, prosperity and sustainable development in a multi – polar world. They emphasized the importance of deepening the India-EU Strategic Partnership which would not only benefit both sides but also have a far-reaching positive impact globally. The leaders also expressed their strong support to the India-EU Trade and Technology Council that would serve as an innovative platform towards closer engagement in the critical areas of trade, trusted technologies and security. They agreed to coordinate efforts, both bilaterally and at the EU level, to take forward key connectivity initiatives including India-Middle East-Europe Economic Corridor in which India, Germany and EU are members as well as the EU Initiative Global Gateway.
12. Both leaders underscored the crucial importance of a comprehensive Free Trade Agreement, Investment Protection Agreement and an Agreement on Geographical Indications between the European Union and India, while calling for an early conclusion of the negotiations.
13. Both leaders unequivocally condemned terrorism and violent extremism in all its forms and manifestations, including the use of terrorist proxies and cross-border terrorism. Both sides agreed that terrorism remains a serious threat to international peace and stability. They further called for concerted action against all terrorist groups, including groups proscribed by the United Nations Security Council (UNSC) 1267 Sanctions Committee. Both sides also called upon all countries to continue to work towards eliminating terrorist safe havens and infrastructure as well as to disrupt terrorist networks and financing in accordance with international law.
14. Both leaders noted with concern the emerging threats from the use of new and emerging technologies for terrorist purposes such as unmanned aircraft systems, use of virtual assets by terrorists and terrorist entities and the misuse of information and communication technologies for radicalization. In this regard they welcomed the adoption of Delhi Declaration on Countering the use of New and Emerging Technologies for Terrorism Purposes adopted during the conduct of UNCTC meetings in India in 2022.
15. Recognizing a shared commitment to combat terrorism and strengthen the framework for global cooperation in this regard, both leaders emphasized the importance of upholding international standards on anti-money laundering and combating the financing of terrorism by all countries, including in FATF. Both sides called for bringing the perpetrators of terrorist acts to justice. Both sides reaffirmed their commitment to hold regular consultations of the Joint Working Group on Counter Terrorism to strengthen channels for real time sharing of intelligence and coordination of counter-terrorism efforts. Both sides also committed to continued exchange of information about sanctions and designations against terror groups and individuals, countering radicalism, and terrorists’ use of the internet and cross-border movement of terrorists.
16. With a view to ensuring closer collaboration to prevent, suppress, investigate and prosecute criminals, including crime related to terrorism, India and Germany concluded the Mutual Legal Assistance Treaty in Criminal Matters (MLAT). Both leaders agreed that the India-Germany MLAT is an important milestone in strengthening security cooperation between the two countries that will enable sharing of information and evidence, mutual capacity building and sharing of best practices between the two countries.
17. As strategic partners with a shared interest in deepening security cooperation, both sides concluded the Agreement on the Exchange and Mutual Protection of Classified Information thereby creating a legal framework for cooperation and collaboration between Indian and German entities and providing guidance on how classified information should be handled, protected and transmitted.
18. With a view to better appreciating foreign policy perspectives in key regions across the world, both governments decided to establish an India-Germany Dialogue on West Asia and North Africa (WANA) between the respective Foreign Ministries, which would be in addition to long-standing dialogue mechanisms on Africa and East Asia. Both governments also expressed satisfaction with regular consultations on key thematic issues of mutual concern including policy planning, cyber-security, cyber issues and United Nations.
19. Recognizing the need for a deeper understanding of each other’s perspectives, including amongst think tanks and foreign and security policy experts, both governments underscored the usefulness of India-Germany Track 1.5 dialogue between Indian Council of World Affairs (ICWA), the Research and Information System for Developing Countries (RIS) and MEA from the Indian side and German Institute for Global and Area Studies (GIGA), the German Institute for International and Security Affairs (SWP) and the German Federal Foreign Office. The next meeting of this dialogue format is planned for November 2024. Both governments also appreciated the launch of a Track 1.5 Dialogue on East Asia and agreed that these exchanges help both sides better align and coordinate their outreach. With a view to sustaining this momentum, both sides agreed to convene the next edition of the Track 1.5 Dialogue Mechanisms at the earliest opportunity.
20. Both sides are committed to promoting a free, open, inclusive, peaceful and prosperous Indo-Pacific built on international law, mutual respect for sovereignty, and peaceful resolution of disputes, and underpinned by effective regional institutions. Both sides reaffirmed their unwavering support for ASEAN’s unity and centrality. The Government of India welcomed Germany’s leadership in the capacity-building pillar of the Indo-Pacific Oceans Initiative (IPOI) and its commitment of up to 20 Million EUR via a competitive call for ideas under its International Climate Initiative in 2022 to strengthen the resilience of Pacific Island States against climate-related loss and damage.
21. Germany congratulated India on its successful G20 Presidency which brought the development agenda to centre stage in G20. Both Leaders acknowledged that from initiating a platform on Compact with Africa (CwA) during the German G20 Presidency to inclusion of the African Union as a permanent member of the G20 during India’s Presidency, the G20 has come a long way to ensure that the voice of the Global South is amplified. India and Germany expressed their support to the priorities set by the Brazilian G20 Presidency, especially Global Governance Reforms.
Strengthening Defence and Strategic Cooperation
22. Recognizing the shared goal of intensifying defence ties between the two countries, the Government of India welcomed the efforts of the German Federal Government to facilitate faster export clearances, including through favourable regulatory decisions such as the General Authorisation/General Licences (AGG) regime. Both sides committed to supporting strategic exports to India and encouraged co-development, co-production and joint research between the respective defence industries. Both governments appreciated the defence roundtable held in New Delhi on 24 October, to strengthen the defense industrial partnership between India and Germany.
23. In addition to regular visits and increasing interactions between the armed forces, both sides look forward to the next High Defence Committee (HDC) meeting to be held in India next year with a view to developing defence cooperation as a key pillar of the Strategic Partnership between India and Germany. India and Germany also agreed to finalize cooperation in peacekeeping related training between the Centre for UN Peacekeeping (CUNPK), New Delhi and its counterpart in Germany, the Bundeswehr United Nations Training Centre in Hammelburg (GAFUNTC) and looked forward to the Peacekeeping Ministerial Meeting in Berlin in 2025.
24. Both sides stressed the importance of the Indo-Pacific for prosperity and security as well as for addressing global challenges. Germany will enhance its engagement with the region in line with the Federal Government’s policy guidelines for the Indo-Pacific. Both sides also highlighted the importance of freedom of navigation and of unimpeded maritime routes in accordance with International Law, as reflected in the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) 1982, in all maritime domains including in the Indo-Pacific. In this context, both governments declared their joint intent to conclude a Memorandum of Arrangement regarding mutual logistics support and exchange between the armed forces of India and Germany to further intensify defence and security ties and to establish a basis for provision of mutual logistics support including in the Indo-Pacific theatre. With a view to deepening cooperation in the Indo-Pacific, Germany will permanently deploy a Liaison Officer in the Information Fusion Centre – Indian Ocean Region (IFC-IOR) at Gurugram to monitor the marine traffic in IOR, further augmenting close cooperation in this region.
25. Both sides welcomed Germany’s growing engagement in the Indo-Pacific region in the field of security and defence cooperation and appreciated the successful cooperation of the Indian and German air forces during exercise TARANG SHAKTI in August 2024 as well as the port call in Goa and joint naval exercises between the German Naval Frigate “Baden-Württemberg” along with the Combat Support Ship “Frankfurt Am Main” and the Indian Navy. Germany also welcomed the port call of Indian naval ship INS TABAR to Hamburg in July 2024.
26. Both governments agreed to intensify bilateral exchanges on security and defence issues also through enhancing research, co-development and co-production activities bilaterally, under EU mechanisms and with other partners. In this regard, both sides will support enhanced industry level cooperation in the defence sector with a specific focus on technology collaboration, manufacturing/co-production and co-development of defence platforms and equipment. Germany also welcomes India’s application for observer status in the Eurodrone Programme of OCCAR (Organisation for Joint Armament Co-operation).
Partnering for Critical and Emerging Technologies, Science and Innovation
27. Both leaders expressed their appreciation on the successful 50 years of long standing collaboration in science and technology between the two countries and reaffirmed their support to expand it further through launching the ‘India-Germany Innovation and Technology Partnership Roadmap’ which will serve as a guideline to the public and private sectors and research institutions of the two countries to take forward our cooperation in the areas of renewable energy, start-ups, semiconductors, AI and quantum technologies, climate risk and sustainable resource management, climate change adaptation as well as agroecology Both leaders further identified space and space technologies as an important and promising area for future prosperity, development, and possible cooperation.
28. The two leaders expressed their satisfaction at the growing exchanges between the two countries in the field of research & education and growing number of Indian students studying in Germany. Both leaders also acknowledged the flagship role of the Indo-German Science and Technology Centre (IGSTC) in promoting bilateral industry-academia strategic research and development partnerships. Both leaders welcomed the recent initiatives of IGSTC and signing of Joint Declaration of Intent to support 2+2 projects in the field of advanced materials. Understanding the importance of IGSTC, both leaders expressed their desire to expand and forge new partnerships anchored in shared values and driven by innovation led technology development and manufacturing.
29. Both Leaders acknowledged the launching of the first ever basic research consortia model between the two countries namely, International Research Training Group (IRTG), jointly by Department of Science and Technology (DST) & German Research Foundation (DFG) with the involvement of first group of researchers from IISER Thiruvananthapuram and Würzburg University on Photoluminescence in Supramolecular Matrices. Underpinning science and innovation landscape, they expressed their desire to initiate an Indo-German Innovation and Incubation Exchange Programme to leverage collective expertise and capacity for fostering scientific innovation and incubation ecosystems of academic & research institutions.
30. Both Leaders also expressed their appreciation and satisfaction over the high level of engagement as exemplified by India’s participation in mega-science facilities at Facility for Anti-Proton and Ion Research (FAIR) and Deutsche Elektronen Synchrotron (DESY) in Germany. They extended their commitment including financials to ensure timely execution of the FAIR facility. The two leaders also acknowledge the continuation of the cooperation at the synchrotron radiation facility PETRA-III and the free-electron laser facility FLASH at DESY.
31. Both governments welcomed the steadily increasing partnerships in Higher Education which facilitate dual and joint degrees and intensify collaborative research and academic and institutional exchanges between Universities and Institutions of Higher Education. In particular, both sides expressed their appreciation and full support for the first ever Indo-German joint Masters degree programme in “Water Security & Global Change”, a joint initiative of TU Dresden, RWTH-Aachen and IIT-Madras (IITM) funded by DAAD as well as a new initiative of TU Dresden and IITM to conclude an agreement establishing a “transCampus” to deepen bilateral cooperation in teaching, research, innovation and entrepreneurship. Both governments also welcomed the signing of the MoU between IIT Kharagpur and the DAAD, which will enable joint funding for Indo-German university cooperation projects. Both sides expressed their strong support for the dedicated call of the “German Indian Academic Network for Tomorrow” (GIANT) under SPARC (Scheme for Promotion of Academic and Research Collaboration) highlighting cooperation between Indian and German universities.
32. With a view to further strengthening digital and technology partnerships between India and Germany, both governments agreed to share experience and expertise in digital public infrastructure (DPI), e.g., to explore ways in which Germany can leverage India’s expertise in DPI and the strengths of the Indian IT industry to drive innovation and digital transformation in both countries. As an important forum for exchanges on digital topics such as internet governance, tech regulations, digital transformation of economy, and emerging digital technologies, both sides welcomed the finalization of the Work Plan for 2023-24 formulated by the Indo-German Digital Dialogue (IGDD).
33. Both sides will endeavour to leverage AI to advance the SDG, recognizing the need for an innovation-friendly, balanced, inclusive, human-centric and risk-based approach to the governance of AI. Digital solutions such as image detection and AI are playing an important role in revolutionising agriculture by assisting farmers and enhancing agricultural productivity, climate resilience, carbon sinks and sustainability. Both countries are running national programmes to facilitate the growth of digital agriculture and have agreed to intensify their Cooperation in Digital Agriculture, AI and IoT to foster ongoing cooperation, innovation and exchanges for modernising agriculture.
34. Both governments underlined the strategic importance of collaboration in the field of critical and emerging technologies, innovation and skill development. Reaffirming the priorities for bilateral cooperation, as laid down in the Innovation and Technology Partnership Roadmap, both governments agreed to focus on collaboration in innovation, skill development and critical and emerging technologies. Forging closer linkages between the industry and academia of the two countries in key technology areas would be prioritized, in recognition of a shared commitment to ensuring an open, inclusive and secure technology architecture, built on mutual trust and respect, and reflecting shared values and democratic principles. Based on that, the two countries would achieve outcome oriented and mutually beneficial technology collaboration in identified sectors.
35. In furthering cooperation in the field of research in disaster mitigation, tsunami warnings, coastal hazards, early warning systems, disaster risk reduction and oceanography, polar sciences, biology and biogeochemistry, geophysics and geology, both Governments welcomed the signing of the Memorandum of Understanding between Indian National Centre for Ocean Information Services (INCOIS) and Helmholtz-Zentrum Potsdam – Deutsches GeoForschungsZentrum, and between National Centre for Polar and Ocean Research (NCPOR) and AlfredWegener-Institut, Helmholtz-Zentrum für Polar- und Meeresforschung (AWI).
36. Both Governments also welcomed the bilateral agreement in the biological, physical and mathematical sciences between National Centre for Biological Sciences (NCBS) and International Centre for Theoretical Sciences (ICTS), both centres of the Tata Institute of Fundamental Research (TIFR), under the Department of Atomic Energy (DAE), India and Max-Planck-Gesellschaft (MPG), Germany. This agreement will facilitate the exchange of scientists, including students and research staff, between the various Max Planck Institutes with ICTS and NCBS.
37. Both Leaders noted with appreciation the collaboration between M/s New Space India Ltd and M/s GAF AG for upgrading the international ground station at Neustrelitz, Germany for the reception and processing of data from OceanSat – 3 and RISAT – 1A satellites.
Partnership for a Green and Sustainable Future
38. Both sides acknowledged the need for green, sustainable, climate resilient and inclusive development to achieve net zero emissions. Both governments aim to substantially enhance bilateral, trilateral and multilateral cooperation in climate action and sustainable development. Both sides acknowledged the progress achieved thus far under the Indo-German Green and Sustainable Development Partnership (GSDP). This partnership, guided by shared commitments, seeks to accelerate the implementation of the goals outlined in the Paris Agreement and the SDGs. In this context, both sides stressed the need to work jointly for an ambitious outcome of the upcoming UNFCCC COP29, in particular on the New Collective Quantified Goal (NCQG). Both sides will respond positively to the outcomes of COP28, including the first Global Stocktake, in light of national circumstances.
39. Both sides appreciated the stocktaking of progress during the Ministerial meeting on the GSDP objectives. To contribute to the implementation of the GSDP, both sides are committed to regular dialogue within the existing working groups and other bilateral formats and initiatives. The next meeting of the Ministerial Mechanism shall take place at the latest within the framework of the next India-Germany Inter-Governmental Consultations, to conduct a stocktaking of the progress on GSDP objectives to achieve the Paris Agreement goals and SDGs. Both sides reaffirmed their intention to closely cooperate on combatting climate change and therefore expressed their intention to hold a meeting of the Indo-German Climate Working Group in the near future.
40. Under the umbrella of the GSDP, both sides inter alia:
a. Launched the Indo-German Green Hydrogen Roadmap. The Leaders agreed that the Roadmap will help support India’s ambition for production, usage and export of Green Hydrogen while also contributing to a swifter adoption of Green Hydrogen as a sustainable source of energy in both countries
b. Launched the GSDP Dashboard, a publicly accessible online tool, which showcases the intensive cooperation between Germany and India under the GSDP. It gives an overview of key innovations and the broad range of experience covered by India-Germany cooperation. It facilitates stocktaking of the joint progress towards achieving GSDP objectives, and provides key information to relevant stakeholders on innovative solutions for global challenges.
c. Signed a Joint Declaration of Intent to renew and further elevate the partnership in accordance with a shared vision to promoting in India sustainable urban mobility for all, recognizing the importance of green and sustainable urbanization for inclusive social and economic development and the strong results of the Green Urban Mobility Partnership since its establishment in 2019.
d. Highly appreciated the achievements and vision for the future of the International Solar Alliance (ISA) and agreed to intensify our cooperation within ISA.
e. Appreciated the cooperation in the area of halting deforestation and degradation and reversing the trend by restoring forest landscapes in support of the implementation of the Rio Conventions and the SDGs.
41. The leaders acknowledged that the Indo-German Energy Forum (IGEF), through its various activities, has played a pivotal role in strengthening the general bilateral economic relations between Germany and India, promoting economic growth, and addressing global climate change challenges.
42. Both sides underscored the role of the 4th Global RE-INVEST Renewable Energy Investors Meet & Expo, held in September 2024 in Gandhinagar with Germany as a partner country, in bringing together key stakeholders in the renewable energy sector. Both governments recalled the ‘India-Germany Platform for Investments in Renewable Energy Worldwide’ which was launched during RE-INVEST as a key initiative to fast-track renewable energy investments, foster business collaborations and expand global supply chains. The platform will accelerate the expansion of renewable energy in India and worldwide through exchanges on green financing, technology and business opportunities.
43. Both governments expressed their wish to continue to strengthen the cooperation through the Joint Working Group on Biodiversity and acknowledged that CBD COP 16 marks a crucial moment in the global effort to implement the goals of the Global Biodiversity Framework.
44. Recalling the deliberations and outcomes of the Joint Working Group on Waste management and Circular Economy which has created opportunities by intensifying exchanges on experiences and technologies between the two countries, both sides agreed to explore the possibility of deepening cooperation within these structures, for instance, focusing future work on inter alia Solar Waste recycling. They appreciated the Indo-German environment cooperation on the effective and efficient implementation of ambitious objectives and policies in order to prevent waste, especially plastics, from entering the marine environment. India and Germany agreed to closely cooperate towards establishing a global legally binding agreement on plastic pollution.
45. Both leaders acknowledged the progress made under the Triangular Development Cooperation (TDC), which pools mutual strengths and experiences to offer sustainable, viable and inclusive projects in third countries as per their priorities to support the achievement of SDGs and climate targets in Africa, Asia and beyond. Both sides welcomed the encouraging results of the pilot projects in Cameroon, Ghana and Malawi, and the progress made in the ongoing initiatives with Benin and Peru. In view of the successful implementation of the aforementioned initiatives, both governments have agreed to commence upscaling of the pilot projects with Cameroon (agriculture), Malawi (women entrepreneurship) and Ghana (horticulture) in 2024 and beyond. Furthermore, both sides welcomed the start of the three millet related pilot projects: two with Ethiopia and one with Madagascar. Additionally, both sides have launched the institutional mechanism to reach out to the partners, select and implement their joint initiatives on a full scale and to this end, both governments established a Joint Steering Committee and a Joint Implementation Group.
46. The leaders reaffirmed that Gender Equality is of fundamental importance and investing in the empowerment of women and girls has a multiplier effect in implementing the 2030 Agenda. They reiterated their commitment to encourage women-led development and enhancing womens’ full, equal, effective and meaningful participation as decision-makers for addressing global challenges inclusively while noting Germany’s Feminist Foreign and Development Policies in this regard. Both sides reaffirmed their desire to strengthen Indo-German cooperation on promoting the critical role of women in green and sustainable development.
47. In addition, both sides welcomed the milestones already achieved with respect to the existing initiatives and new commitments for financial and technical cooperation under the framework of the GSDP, as follows:
a. New commitments in all core areas of the GSDP of more than 1 billion EUR as agreed during the negotiations on development cooperation between the Government of India and the Government of the Federal Republic of Germany in September 2024, adding up to accumulated commitments of around 3.2 billion EUR since beginning of the GSDP in 2022;
b. Under the Indo-German Renewable Energy Partnership, the cooperation focused on innovative solar energy, green hydrogen, other renewables, grid integration, storage and investments in the renewable energy sector to facilitate an energy transition and to address the need for a reliable, round the clock renewable power supply.
c. The “Agroecology and Sustainable Management of Natural Resources” cooperation benefits the vulnerable rural population and small-scale farmers in India by fostering income, food security, climate resilience, soil health, biodiversity, forest ecosystems and water security.
d. Both sides reiterated their intention to continue their successful collaboration on sustainable urban development.
Building resilience through Trade and Economic collaboration
48. Both leaders hailed the consistent high performance in terms of bilateral trade between the two countries in the recent years and encouraged stakeholders in India and Germany to further strengthen trade and investment flows. The leaders also noted the strong two-way investments between India and Germany and the positive impacts of such investments in diversifying the global supply chains. In this context, the leaders expressed confidence that the APK 2024, the bi-annual flagship forum of German Business with participation of top-level business executives from Germany, is a crucial platform to showcase the immense opportunities available in India for German businesses.
49. Both sides underlined the long-standing presence of German businesses in India and Indian businesses in Germany and agreed to work towards deepening economic and trade linkages between the two countries. In this context, both sides welcomed the holding of the meeting of the India-Germany CEO Forum which serves as a high-level platform to engage business and industry leaders from India and Germany. They also underlined the achievements of the Indo-German Fast Track Mechanism to resolve trade and investment related issues, and are ready to continue its operation.
50. In recognition of the importance of Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs)/Mittelstand in economic growth and job creation, both sides acknowledged the growth in bilateral investment and the success of the ‘Make in India Mittelstand’ Programme, which supports German Mittelstand enterprises seeking to invest and do business in India. In a similar vein, both governments also recognised the key role played by start-ups in fostering innovation, and commended the German Accelerator (GA) for successfully facilitating start-ups to address the Indian market, and welcomed plans to establish its presence in India. Both sides noted that a corresponding programme to assist Indian start-ups in gaining market access in Germany could further enhance economic cooperation between the two countries.
Strengthening Labour Markets, Mobility and People-to-People Ties
51. As bilateral cooperation on skilled migration expands across multiple fronts, involving collaboration between federal and state governments, as well as private sector stakeholders, both sides committed to full implementation of the provisions of the Migration and Mobility Partnership Agreement (MMPA). In line with the commitments outlined in the MMPA both sides remain dedicated to promoting fair and legal labor migration. This approach is guided by international standards that ensure migrant workers are treated with dignity and respect, including fair recruitment practices, transparent visa processes, and the protection of workers’ rights. By focusing on these principles, both countries aim to facilitate the mobility of skilled workers in a manner that benefits all parties while safeguarding against exploitation and ensuring compliance with international labor standards.
52. Building on the MMPA, the two sides concluded a JDI in the field of Employment and Labour, to enhance bilateral cooperation and exchange in areas of mutual interest between the respective ministries. The German side informed that it will support a feasibility study on international reference classification, a G20 commitment undertaken by the Indian G20 presidency in 2023. Both leaders look forward to the signing of the Memorandum of Understanding in the field of occupational diseases, rehabilitation and vocational training of workers with disabilities between the Employees’ State Insurance Corporation (ESIC), the Directorate General of Employment (DGE) and the German Social Accident Insurance (DGUV).
53. Both leaders noted that Indian professionals comprise over 1/4th of all blue card holders in Germany and that Indian students now represent the largest cohort of international students in Germany. Regarding this, they recognized the complementarities that exist between the requirements of skills and talents in Germany and the vast reservoir of young, educated and skilled persons in India, who can be an asset to the German labour market. The Federal Employment Agency will deepen the existing exchange with the National Skill Development Council, India (NSDC) and other similar Government agencies at national and state levels. Both sides welcomed the launch of the new national strategy of the German Federal government to promote skilled migration from India.
54. Both leaders also expressed satisfaction on the signing of a Memorandum of Understanding on Skill Development and Vocational Education and Training which would leverage the strengths of India and Germany towards creating a pool of skilled workforce in India and strengthening the participation of women, especially in the areas of green skills. Both sides agreed to include elements of facilitating international mobility of labour.
55. Both sides remain committed to the goal of expanding the teaching of the German language in India, including in secondary schools, universities and vocational education centers. They encouraged Indian and German States, culture centers and educational institutions to further promote the teaching of each other’s languages in India and Germany, including the training of language teachers. Both sides welcomed the joint efforts of the DAAD and the Goethe Institute to develop a format for the formalized training and further education of German teachers leading to a university certificate recognized in India.
56. Both sides reaffirmed the contribution of highly skilled professionals for economic growth, noted with satisfaction the results achieved under the programme “Partnering in Business with Germany”, and renewed the JDI on advanced training of corporate executives and junior executives from India.
57. With the Migration and Mobility Partnership Agreement (MMPA), both sides also agreed to address irregular migration. For this purpose, both sides established a cooperation in the field of return since the entry into force of the MMPA. Both sides welcomed the progress achieved so far and underline the importance of further developing and streamlining cooperation through appropriate procedural arrangements.
58. The leaders welcomed the growing ties between the two sides and their respective nationals. They acknowledged the wide range of Consular issues stemming from these growing ties and the need for dialogue on all matters related to Consular issues. They agreed to work towards early establishment of an appropriate format for a bilateral dialogue on various Consular, Visa and other issues affecting nationals of the other side residing in their respective territories.
59. Both sides acknowledged the role of their youth as cultural ambassadors and catalysts for innovation and promoting people – people linkages between the two countries. In this context, both leaders stressed on the importance of youth cooperation and noted the proposal for establishing forum for youth exchanges and delegations between both sides. Both sides also agree to facilitate student exchanges on a mutual basis.
60. Both sides noted with satisfaction the substantial work being done in the field of culture and welcomed efforts towards expanding scope of the Memorandum of Understanding on Museum Cooperation between Indian and German national museums such as the Prussian Heritage Foundation and the National Gallery of Modern Art, India.
61. In line with the G20 New Delhi Leader’s Declaration (2023), both leaders underscored the intention to cooperate closely with regards to the restitution and protection of cultural goods and the fight against illicit trafficking of cultural property at national, regional and state levels to enable its return and restitution to the country and community of origin as relevant, and called for sustained dialogue and action in that endeavour.
62. Both Governments also appreciated substantial cultural and academic exchanges made possible via initiatives such as the establishment of Indian academic chairs at universities in Germany.
63. Both leaders expressed satisfaction at the deliberations held at the 7th IGC and reaffirmed their commitment to further expand and deepen the Indo-German Strategic Partnership. Chancellor Scholz thanked Prime Minister Modi for his warm hospitality and conveyed that Germany looks forward to hosting the next IGC.
New Delhi, 25 October, 2024
Source – German Government
List of Outcomes: Visit of Chancellor of Germany, Olaf Scholz, to India for the 7th Intergovernmental Consultations
Posted by the Indian Prime Minister Office
New Delhi, 25 October 2024
I. DOCUMENTS CONCLUDED
1. Roadmap on Innovation and Technology – New and Emerging Technologies
2. Launch of Green Hydrogen Roadmap document – Green Energy
3. Mutual Legal Assistance Treaty (MLAT) in Criminal Matters – Security
4. Agreement on the Exchange and Mutual Protection of Classified Information – Security
5. JDI on Green Urban Mobility Partnership-II – Urban Mobility
6. JDI on 2+2 Calls for Advanced Materials under IGSTC – Science & Technology
7. MoU between Max-Planck-Gesellschaft e.V. (MPG) and International Centre for Theoretical Sciences (ICTS), Tata Institute of Fundamental Research (TIFR) – Science & Technology
8. MoU between Max-Planck-Gesellschaft e.V. (MPG) and National Centre for Biological Sciences (NCBS), Tata Institute of Fundamental Research (TIFR) – Science & Technology
9. JDI on Innovation and Incubation Exchange Programme between DST and German Academic Exchange Service (DAAD) – Start-ups
10. MoU between Indian National Centre for Ocean Information Services (INCOIS) and German Research Centre for Geosciences (GFZ) on Disaster Mitigation – Environment & Science
11. MoU on Polar and Ocean Research between National Centre for Polar and Ocean Research (NCPOR) and Alfred-Wegener Institute Helmholtz Zentrum fuer Polar and Meeresforschung (AWI) – Environment & Science
12. JDI for Collaborative Research and Development in Infectious Disease Genomics between Council of Scientific and Industrial Research – Institute of Genomics and Integrative Biology (CSIR – IGIB) and Leipzig University – Health
13. JDI for the partnership on Mobile Suitcase Lab for Diagnostic purposes between Council of Scientific and Industrial Research – Institute of Genomics and Integrative Biology (CSIR – IGIB), All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS), Leipzig University and Industry partners in India – Health
14. JDI on India-Germany Managerial Training Program (IGMTP) – Economy & Commerce
15. MoU on Cooperation in the Field of Skill Development and Vocational Education and Training – Skill Development
16. Joint Declaration of Intent of Labour and Employment – Labour & Employment
17. JDI between IIT Kharagpur and German Academic Exchange Service (DAAD) to implement co-funded Joint Research Programme ‘German India Academic Network for Tomorrow (GIANT)’ – Education & Research
18. Memorandum of Agreement between IIT Madras and TU Dresden to establish an intensified partnership known as ‘TransCampus’ – Education & Research
II. KEY ANNOUNCEMENTS
19. Placing a German Liaison Officer in the IFC-IOR
20. German support for India’s Observer status in the Eurodrone programme
21. German projects and funding commitment of 20 Mn Euros under Indo-Pacific Oceans Initiative (IPOI)
22. Establishing Regional Consultations between the Foreign offices of India and Germany (Africa, West Asia and North Africa)
23. Millet related Pilot projects in Madagascar and Ethiopia and full scale projects in Cameroon, Ghana and Malawi under Triangular Development Cooperation (TDC) framework
24. Launch of GSDP Dashboard
25. Establishment of first International Research Training Group between India and Germany
III. EVENTS
26. Holding of the 18th Asia-Pacific Conference of German Business (APK 2024)
27. Holding of a Defence RoundTable on the sidelines of the APK 2024
28. Indo Pacific Deployment of German Naval ships: Joint exercises between Indian and German Navies and Port calls of German ships in Goa
Read this release in: Urdu , Hindi
Source – Prime Minister’s Office
Pressekonferenz von Bundeskanzler Scholz in Neu-Delhi:
Bundeskanzler Olaf Scholz hat bei seinem Besuch in Neu-Delhi nachdrücklich für ein Freihandelsabkommen zwischen der Europäischen Union und Indien geworben. „Jetzt ist die Zeit, das nach so langen Jahren der Verhandlungen zum Abschluss zu bringen“, sagte der Bundeskanzler in einer Pressekonferenz am Freitag.
Freitag, 25. Oktober 2024
Indien sei ein Land mit großen Wachstumsperspektiven, „und wir als Deutschland und Europa wollen dabei sein“, sagte Bundeskanzler Scholz in einer Pressekonferenz am Freitag in Neu-Delhi. Ein Freihandelsabkommen der EU mit Indien würde noch mehr Investitionen und Handelsaustausch ermöglichen und auch den Austausch von Wissenschaft und Arbeitskräften befördern.
Zudem betonte der Bundeskanzler, dass es in Bezug auf den russischen Angriffskrieg auf die Ukraine gut sei, „dass zum Beispiel ein Land wie Indien den festen Willen hat, hilfreich zu sein“, um bei Friedensgesprächen weiterzukommen. Vor der Pressekonferenz hatte der Kanzler an der Eröffnung einer neuen Zentrale von Airbus India teilgenommen. Außerdem hatten zurvor die deutsch-indischen Regierungskonsultationen stattgefunden.
Mitschrift der Pressekonferenz
Bundeskanzler Scholz: Wir haben heute unsere Regierungskonsultation hier in Indien gehabt. Sie haben, wie Sie wissen, nun schon eine lange Tradition mit gutem Erfolg. Der erste Tag hat jetzt hier in Indien stattgefunden.
Nun freue ich mich auf Fragen.
Frage: Herr Bundeskanzler, Sie haben heute mehrfach vom richtigen Zeitpunkt Ihrer Reise gesprochen. Inwiefern war es jetzt der richtige Zeitpunkt bei zwei Themen, zum einen bei dem Thema, den Freihandel anstoßen zu wollen, sodass das endlich zum Abschluss kommt, und inwiefern war das zum anderen der richtige Zeitpunkt beim Thema der Vermittlung, beim Angebot Indiens, eine Mittlerrolle im Angriffskrieg Russlands gegen die Ukraine spielen zu wollen?
Bundeskanzler Scholz: Die wirtschaftlichen Beziehungen zwischen Indien und Deutschland entwickeln sich sehr positiv. Hier finden jetzt sehr, sehr viele Investitionen statt. Es gibt einen regen Handelsaustausch. Wir haben auch einen guten Austausch, was Wissenschaft betrifft und was Arbeitskräfte angeht. Aber gleichzeitig ist klar, dass dabei noch mehr möglich ist. Das würde natürlich erheblich erleichtert, wenn die Europäische Union und Indien mit den Verhandlungen über ein Freihandelsabkommen bald fertig würden. Mir ist wichtig, zu sagen: Jetzt ist die Zeit, das nach so langen Jahren der Verhandlungen zum Abschluss zu bringen. – Ich werde auch weiterhin sehr aktiv dafür werben, dass wir das tun, und zwar mit Indien – das ist wichtig –, aber auch mit vielen anderen Ländern.
Ich denke, dass wir die Art und Weise, wie Freihandelsabkommen ausgehandelt werden, dramatisch ändern müssen. Sie müssen schneller gelingen, und sie müssen auch weniger abhängig von einzelnen Mitgliedstaaten sein. Deshalb schlage ich schon seit einiger Zeit vor, dass wir als Europäische Union Freihandelsabkommen abschließen, die sich ausschließlich auf europäische Regeln beziehen und deshalb mit qualifizierter Mehrheit im Rat und mit normaler Mehrheit im Parlament beschlossen werden können und dann gelten, und dass sie durch ein Abkommen über die Fragen, denen Länder zustimmen müssen, ergänzt werden, dem man beitreten kann, sodass wir endlich viele Abkommen zustande bekommen.
Ein Abkommen mit Indien wäre eines, bei dem das die höchste Priorität hat. Das ist ein Land mit großen Wachstumsperspektiven, und wir als Deutschland und Europa wollen dabei sein.
Ansonsten gilt es jetzt, zu schauen, welche Möglichkeiten bestehen, damit der Krieg, den Russland gegen die Ukraine begonnen hat, nicht immer weiter mit dieser Brutalität fortgesetzt wird, sondern zu einem Ende kommt. Es geht immer – darüber sind wir uns hier klar – um einen gerechten Frieden für die Ukraine, der ihre Integrität und Souveränität im Blick hat. Deshalb sage ich auch, dass Deutschland weiterhin aufgefordert sein wird, die Ukraine zu unterstützen, damit sie sich verteidigen kann. Das tun wir in Europa am stärksten.
Deshalb ist es auch ein gutes Zeichen, dass gerade jetzt die G7-Staaten das getan haben, was sie auf dem Treffen in Apulien in Italien angekündigt haben, nämlich einen 50-Milliarden-Dollar-Kredit auf den Weg zu bringen. Damit besteht Klarheit für die Ukraine. Sie kann sich die notwendige Sicherheit beschaffen, die sie braucht, um sich verteidigen zu können. Damit ist für den russischen Präsidenten auch klar, dass das Aussitzen nicht hilft und dass man nicht darauf warten kann, dass die Unterstützung nachlässt.
Darum ist jetzt auch der Zeitpunkt, auszuloten, ob Möglichkeiten bestehen. Wir haben auf internationalen Konferenzen viele, viele Dinge unternommen, um Friedensgespräche möglich zu machen. Zuletzt fand eine Konferenz auf dem Bürgenstock in der Schweiz statt. Sie hat mit der Perspektive geendet, eine weitere zu haben, bei der Russland dabei ist. Es ist gut, dass zum Beispiel ein Land wie Indien den festen Willen hat, hilfreich zu sein, um dabei weiterzukommen. Wir brauchen mehr solche Länder. Indien ist auf alle Fälle eines, das diesbezüglich einen sehr ernsten Willen hat und auch wirklich eine gute Rolle spielen kann.
Frage: Herr Bundeskanzler, Indien allein hat 1,4 Milliarden Menschen, sogar mehr. Indien ist auch noch Teil eines Konglomerats, eines Bundes, der sogenannten BRICS-Staaten. Wie glauben Sie, wie glauben wir, dem überhaupt etwas entgegenhalten zu können, sei es Deutschland, sei es Europa oder die G7, meinetwegen sogar die G20. Was können wir dagegen halten?
Wenn Sie erlauben, noch eine Frage zur Innenpolitik: Sie haben zu einem Industriegipfel eingeladen. Der Wirtschaftsminister hat ein Wirtschaftspapier vorgelegt. Jetzt hat auch Ihr liberaler Koalitionspartner Herr Lindner zu einem Wirtschafts- und Industrietreffen eingeladen. Das wirkt, ehrlich gesagt, ein bisschen unkoordiniert. Was sagt das über den Zustand der Koalition aus? Denken Sie, die Koalition wird gemeinsam Weihnachten feiern?
Bundeskanzler Scholz: Weihnachten wird immer gefeiert.
Zu den konkreten Fragen, die Sie gestellt haben: Ich bin dezidiert der Meinung, dass es falsch wäre, die Welt aufzuteilen und den Bedeutungszuwachs vieler Länder im Süden der Welt, also von Indonesien, Indien, um zwei zu nennen, von Ländern wie Südafrika und Brasilien, als Problem zu betrachten. Das sind Partner für die Welt von morgen. Es ist gerade unsere Aufgabe als Deutschland in Europa, als Europäische Union, als die Länder, die einmal die klassischen Industrieländer genannt worden sind, diese Partnerschaft auch von sich aus zu wollen und vorzubereiten. Wenn sich diese Länder jetzt sich zu Wort melden, dann ist das kein Problem, sondern Teil dessen, was wir uns für die zukünftige Welt vorstellen, damit das miteinander gelingen kann. Das ist der Weg.
Einen Teil des Weges haben wir gezeichnet: Deutschland und Namibia haben es zusammen mit dem Generalsekretär der Vereinten Nationen innerhalb von zwei Jahren möglich gemacht, dass die Vereinten Nationen jetzt einen „Pact for the Future“ angenommen haben, der auch die Reform internationaler Institutionen mit vorsieht und dazu beitragen soll, dass sie auf die Zukunft vorbereitet sind.
Wenn wir es richtig machen, kann die multipolare Welt eine bessere Welt sein als heute. Das setzt aber voraus, dass bestimmte Prinzipien immer beachtet werden, und da will ich ganz klar noch einmal sagen: Eines dieser Prinzipien, das in der UN-Charta und an vielen anderen Orten festgelegt ist, ist das Prinzip, dass Grenzen nicht mit Gewalt verschoben werden. Deshalb ist der russische Angriff auf die Ukraine auch ein Angriff auf die Sicherheitsarchitektur nicht nur Europas, sondern der Welt; denn wir haben uns alle in unglaublich vielen Beschlüssen, Dokumenten, Verständigungen immer wieder dazu bekannt, dass die Grenzen nicht mit Gewalt verändert und verschoben werden dürfen.
Was die Lage in Deutschland betrifft, so ist ganz klar: Wir müssen etwas dafür tun, dass unsere Wirtschaft besser wächst. Dazu haben wir bereits mit der Wachstumsinitiative einen ganz wichtigen Aufschlag gemacht, und Stück für Stück, Woche für Woche, kommen Gesetze, die aus dieser Verabredung folgen, in den Deutschen Bundestag. Da ist die gesamte Regierung sehr engagiert. Wir haben in den letzten Jahren viele Entscheidungen getroffen, um Bürokratie abzubauen und die Rahmenbedingungen für Wachstum zu verbessern.
Jetzt geht es darum, das ganz konkret weiter zu betrachten; denn da ist ja etwas zu tun. Die Weltkonjunktur hilft uns nicht, und die Konjunktur in Deutschland hat auch nicht angezogen. Deshalb muss man sich mit allen unterhalten. Ich war jetzt zum Beispiel wieder bei einem meiner regelmäßigen Gespräche mit verschiedenen Verbänden der Wirtschaft – Arbeitgeberverband, Handelskammertag –, mit dem Handwerk und auch natürlich mit der Industrie, und ich werde diese Gespräche in großer Kontinuität immer weiter fortsetzen. Ich habe besprochen, dass ich mich mit den Handwerkern ganz konkret über ihre Fragen unterhalten werde. Wir versuchen gerade, das zu fokussieren, damit das geschehen kann.
Natürlich müssen wir angesichts der Bedeutung, die die Industrie in Deutschland hat, auch ganz konzentriert über die Frage reden: Was kann getan werden, damit die industriellen Perspektiven in Deutschland so optimal wie möglich ausgestaltet werden? Darüber muss man sprechen. Wichtig ist mir allerdings: Wir müssen wegkommen von den „Theaterbühnen“, wir müssen wegkommen davon, dass irgendetwas präsentiert und vorgeschlagen wird, was dann gar nicht von allen akzeptiert und angenommen wird. Es muss um ein großes Miteinander gehen. Deshalb ist mir wichtig, dass wir, wenn wir die industriellen Perspektiven, aber auch andere Fragen betrachten, nicht versuchen, uns irgendwie vorzuführen, sondern dass es darum geht, einen gemeinsamen Konsens zu entwickeln. Wenn das gelingt, dann ist das gut und sicherlich auch etwas, das ein Rat an die Politik in Deutschland ist, der dann sicherlich auch von allen gerne angenommen wird. Aber das will ich unbedingt erreichen: dass nicht immer irgendwas gesagt wird, sondern dass sich alle unterhaken.
Frage: Herr Bundeskanzler, ich würde Sie gerne zu den Berichten über die Verlegung nordkoreanischer Truppen nach Russland fragen: Wie besorgt sind Sie darüber, und welche Möglichkeiten hätte der Westen zu reagieren, wenn diese Soldaten in den Ukraine-Krieg eingreifen?
Außerdem noch eine Nachfrage zu dem Industriegipfel: Warum haben Sie Herrn Lindner und Herrn Habeck eigentlich nicht zu Ihrem Gipfel eingeladen? Damit hätten Sie sich ja vielleicht die Veranstaltung von Herrn Lindner, die er jetzt plant, und das Papier von Herrn Habeck ersparen können.
Bundeskanzler Scholz: Es ist so, dass wir uns alle gemeinsam sehr bemühen müssen darum, dass Dinge vorankommen. Zu den Möglichkeiten des Bundeskanzlers und den Anforderungen an den Bundeskanzler gehört auch, mit Vertretern der Wirtschaft zu sprechen. Das tue ich übrigens oft – meistens ohne dass darüber berichtet wird –, mit oft sehr konkreten und pragmatischen Folgen. In der konkreten Situation ist es meine Aufgabe, ein solches Gespräch zu führen – und das übrigens auch nicht nur an einem Datum, sondern als etwas, wo ich mir schon eine längere Entwicklung vorstelle. Ich erwarte also nicht, dass 24 Stunden später etwas herauskommt; vielmehr soll das ja gemeinschaftlich geschehen. Die Vertraulichkeit ist dazu ganz zentral. Das schließt ja andere nicht aus – weder ihre Aktivitäten noch überhaupt aus dem gemeinsamen Handeln der Bundesregierung, um das es mir ja nun auch immer geht. Wie jeder merkt, verwende ich ja auch sehr viel Zeit darauf, dass Konsense und Entscheidungen zustande kommen. Auch wenn es nicht immer einfach ist, ist das weiter die Aufgabe, der ich nachkomme.
Die Frage der Verlegung von nordkoreanischen Soldaten nach Russland und ihr möglicher Einsatz im Ukrainekrieg ist sehr besorgniserregend; das kann man gar nicht unterschätzen. Das ist schlimm, und das ist natürlich etwas, das die Situation weiter eskaliert. Es zeigt gleichzeitig natürlich auch, dass der russische Präsident in größter Not ist. Er hat sich jetzt ja mit Ländern verbündet, die er für deren Gebaren vor einiger Zeit noch in einer anderen Rolle heftig kritisiert hat. Das ist aber auch wieder ein Grund, dafür zu sorgen, dass wir neben der notwendigen, festen und verlässlichen Unterstützung der Ukraine auch gemeinsam mit der Ukraine ausloten müssen: Wie kommen wir jetzt vielleicht doch zu einem gerechten und fairen Frieden für die Ukraine?
Quelle – Bundesregierung